DiCarlo's Pizza - Wheeling, WV Reviews

the DiCarlo's in Elm Grove is definitely the best pizza around!! you call in, order slices, and they let you know when to pick it up!  sometimes there's a long wait, but usually it doesn't take long.  it is consistenly awesome, whereas sometimes other pizza places have good days and bad days.  the cheese is the best thing about this pizza.  after the pizza is cooked, dough and sauce only, they put the cheese on.  so the cheese is only a little bit melted, and it is delicious!!     also, the slices are only 75 cents!!!  you can't beat… read full review »

If you are ever in the small town of Follansbee, WV, have to try DiCarlo's Buffalo Chicken Pizza.  I was skeptical at first.  Chicken on pizza?  But I am a big hot wing fan so I decided to try it.  I was instantly hooked.  It has perfectly crispy crust, sauce, cheese, shredded chicken and hot sauce.  Dipped in ranch dressing, you couldn't ask for a better treat.  Not only is it delicious but it is also cheap (which is a big plus for me).  A large is only $12.00 and is enough to feed my family of 3 and have left-overs. … read full review »

 I grew up on di carlos pizza and now I am in my mid 50s.Variety is excellent,you can even order meals,drinks while waiting.I have tried alot of pizzas but di carlos is always my favorite.My family when they come back to visit naturally we have to have a di carlos pizza party to welcome everyone.There is hardly any left overs and when there is if it makes it to breakfast is someones breakfast,but usually it is eaten all through the night.You simply can:t beat the… read full review »

DiCarlos pizza is a local favorite of many, including my family. You can buy it buy the slice or a whole tray for cheaper that any other local pizza place. They make the dough thierself. This pizza is very delicious, I especially like it with extra cheese. When my family from out of town comes to visit we always get DiCarlos pizza. It's defintly worth… read full review »

One of the best buffalo chicken pizzas I have tried. Excellent value and I'm always full when I leave! If you pour bleu cheese dressing all over it, it makes it even better. It's a little drive for me, but on a Saturday night, it's nice to go for a little drive and eat some of the best pizza in West… read full review »