All 4 of our dogs sit & wait everynight right before bedtime just waiting for their bedtime snack of Guilt Free treats. They know right where we keep them & as soon as we head for the cupboard they run for the bedroom, knowing what's coming their way. I've had people say to me in the store, when I am wiping the shelf clean of all the bags, "your dogs must love them" "oh ya" I say. As I walk away with all that was there. I wish more stores would carry them.