4.3
13 reviews
Other Mascaras:
  • Average: 4.1
  • High: 5.0
Brand:
CoverGirl
CoverGirl Professional Super Thick Lash Mascara

Read 13 Reviews

REVIEW SNAPSHOT®

by PowerReviews
CoverGirl Professional Super Thick Lash Mascara
 
4.3

(based on 13 reviews)

Ratings Distribution

  • 5 Stars

     

    (8)

  • 4 Stars

     

    (2)

  • 3 Stars

     

    (2)

  • 2 Stars

     

    (1)

  • 1 Stars

     

    (0)

85%

of respondents would recommend this to a friend.

Most Liked Positive Review

 

I swear by CoverGirl Super Thick Lash Mascara!

I have used Covergirl Professional Super Thick Lash Mascara ever since I was a teenager.  In 1968, I was so thrilled, my mom let me start wearing mascara, and this is...Read complete review

I have used Covergirl Professional Super Thick Lash Mascara ever since I was a teenager.  In 1968, I was so thrilled, my mom let me start wearing mascara, and this is the one she bought for me.Over the years I tried to switch once only because the store was out of my color.  And I opted for another brand. I didnt like it and couldnt wait till the new shipment came in!

    A few years back when the company decided to change the packaging, I was concerned the the product would change to.  If they did do some changes to the product, it didnt affect it at all.

I like it because the color I use, being very black goes on with out clumping.  I like the design of the mascara want, it seperates my lashes and covers them completly.I also like the way the tip is designed.  It hold just enough mascara on it for me to glide the tip across the bottom lashes form side to side, instead of combing them on like  I do the top ones.  I've tried this with the other brand I had to use and I had huge clumps on the bottom lashes.

I have never had flaking or smudging.  I like the idea that it comes off with just soap and water.  Or if it gets wet while swimming, I just use a tissue under my eyes and it's clean. With 7 children and grandchildren being born, theres lots of tears at birthing time,  But when there are tears I dont look like a raccoon, I just wipe under my eyes and all ready to renew my mascara again!

I am 57 years old now and still usin this mascara, I dont even change to another kind of mascara with in the same brand name.  My three daughters also use this same mascara, they will change from time to time, but always come back to this one.

One of them ocmmented the other day that when she uses this mascara, she doesnt have to use a sharp object to seperate her lashes.  (GOOD!) :)

 

VS

Most Liked Negative Review

 

One of the most toxic mascaras on the market

I do not recommend Cover Girl Professional Super Thick Lash Mascara for one simple reason, it is highly toxic. I did not think much of it when it irritated my eyes, but then...Read complete review

I do not recommend Cover Girl Professional Super Thick Lash Mascara for one simple reason, it is highly toxic. I did not think much of it when it irritated my eyes, but then decided to go to Skin Deep Cosmetic Safety Database to see how it rates on the toxicity scale with other mascaras. Turned out it was an 8 out of 10, compared to most other mascaras that range 2-5, and that is not even anything considered 'natural' or 'organic', mascaras priced less than this one had a much better rating on the ingredients.As for how it actually functions, it isn't bad, but I would not say it is "*super *thick lash" as it claims. Does go on smooth and the applicator is good. I do not recommend it to anyone with sensitive eyes or any concern about ingredients that are linked to cancer, immunotoxicity, and allergies. Moreover, if you are against animal testing, this product is not for you.I am switching to a different mascara and not waiting until I run out of this one!

Reviewed by 13 customers

Displaying reviews 1-10

Back to top

Previous | Next »

(1 of 1 customers found this review helpful)

 
3.0

not my favorite

Comments about CoverGirl Professional Super Thick Lash Mascara:

I normally buy the professional all in one, but I decided to try this to see if it would give me thicker lashes. First of all, the price is great and the mascara works, but I have too many issues with it to repurchase. I find that the mascara is just too thick on the wand. The end of the wand always has a huge goop on it when I pull it out of the container and even on the wand it looks clumpy before I even use it. Once I get it onto my lashes I find I have trouble getting my lashes to separate. It does not really give me thicker lashes, it just gives me lash clumps. Not the best look. I actually have to work hard with a clean mascara wand to separate the lashes and get them to look normal again. This is a lot more work than the professionals all in one ever was, and more time than I ever want to have to spend on my eyelashes. I prefer a very fast and easy makeup routine. So I would definitely not recommend this mascara unless you are willing to put in extra time every morning.

  • Performance:
  •  
  • Ease of Application:
  •  

Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

 
5.0

Greatful

By 

from San Mateo, CA

Comments about CoverGirl Professional Super Thick Lash Mascara:

I have tried many mascaras throughout the years, and I have found CoverGirl Professional Super Thick Lash Mascara to be the only one that is a great low price and actually stays on my lashes.  Some other inexpensive brands that I have tried have rubbed off or smudged off leaving me with awesome black circles around my eyes at the end of a 10 hour work day. CoverGirl Professional Super Thick Lash Mascara does leave my lashes a little bit thicker than normal, however, I don't really notice a drastic change in thickness to my lashes. I don't really care about the thickness so that part doesn't bother me.  I really only look for mascaras that stay put throughout the day. CoverGirl Professional Super Thick Lash Mascara, however, has not only left the mascara on my lashes during my 10 hour work day, but has kept me coming back to invest again and again.  I highly recommend CoverGirl Professional Super Thick Lash Mascara to anyone who is looking to use an inexpensive, yet quality mascara that doesn't smudge off.

Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

 
4.0

great low priced mascara that doesn't smudge.

By 

from Sparks, NV

Comments about CoverGirl Professional Super Thick Lash Mascara:

I have tried many mascaras throughout the years, and I have found CoverGirl Professional Super Thick Lash Mascara to be the only one that is a great low price and actually stays on my lashes.  Some other inexpensive brands that I have tried have rubbed off or smudged off leaving me with awesome black circles around my eyes at the end of a 10 hour work day. CoverGirl Professional Super Thick Lash Mascara does leave my lashes a little bit thicker than normal, however, I don't really notice a drastic change in thickness to my lashes. I don't really care about the thickness so that part doesn't bother me.  I really only look for mascaras that stay put throughout the day. CoverGirl Professional Super Thick Lash Mascara, however, has not only left the mascara on my lashes during my 10 hour work day, but has kept me coming back to invest again and again.  I highly recommend CoverGirl Professional Super Thick Lash Mascara to anyone who is looking to use an inexpensive, yet quality mascara that doesn't smudge off.

Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

 
5.0

This Mascara is so easy to use!

By 

from Gill, MA

Comments about CoverGirl Professional Super Thick Lash Mascara:

I absolutely love this Covergirl mascara.  I switched from the Almay mascara and noticed the difference right away.  It is easy to apply.  It never looks spidery and it really stays put!  I love the color of it and its looks natural and nicely defines my eyes.  I've been buying this ever since I switched.  It gives me volume and length without looking very fake and clumpy.  There is always the perfect amount on the brush which never clumps or globs.  Whenever I put it on I don't have to apply a billion layers to make it look like I even have any on.  Just a few simple swipes, and my eyes are defined, beautiful and all set to go.  Add a little eyeliner, and I'm all set to go.  I love how my eyes look using this Covergirl Voluminous Mascara on my top and bottom lashes.  It might look a bit fake on my bottom lashes but just don't pull through the lases, instead just pat it on top of the bottom lashes for a more natural look.

  • Affiliation:
  • I received a sample

Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

 
5.0

CoverGirl Professional Super Thick Lash Mascara

By 

from Apex, NC

Comments about CoverGirl Professional Super Thick Lash Mascara:

I swear by this mascara. I have never had a mascara that worked as well or looked as great as CoverGirl Professional Super Thick Lash Mascara. I even prefer CoverGirl Professional Super Thick Lash Mascara to higher brands of mascara.

Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

 
5.0

Super Thick Lash Mascara makes my lashes look great!!

By 

from Longmont, CO

Comments about CoverGirl Professional Super Thick Lash Mascara:

I have tried tons of mascara over the years, but this is one of my favorites! I used to be a Great Lash fan, but then I bought a tube of this Cover Girl Super Thick Lash Mascara in Black and I haven't gone back. I love it because it seems to come off easier at night than some I've tried. I've used the same makeup remover forever and never had a problem getting this mascara off with it. I've also never had trouble with it flaking, like other brands. The thing I love the most is that it goes on quickly and makes my thin and pathetic lashes look great! I also buy it because it isn't as expensive as others I've tried and I would recommend this mascara to anyone who is on a budget, has thin lashes like mine, but is looking to try something new.

  • Affiliation:
  • I received a sample

Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

 
5.0

I love Super Thick Lash Mascara!

By 

from Grand Rapids, MI

Comments about CoverGirl Professional Super Thick Lash Mascara:

I have tried different brands and types of mascaras over the years just to try them out, and I have come back around to CoverGirl Super Thick Lash Mascara - it is truly the best I have tried, including more expensive brands.  I have oily skin, and other brands typically leave smudging under my eyes.  I look like a racoon by the end of the day.  (This is with regular - I don't use waterproof formulas.)  Thick Lash, however, stays put all day with no smudging.  It also goes on without clumps and separates my lashes nicely.  I have long eyelashes but they are not thick, and this does make them appear thicker.  I like the type of applicator brush it comes with - some others are strangely shaped but this one is just right and covers the whole eye.  I typically only need one coat but will use 2 sometimes for a more dramatic look.  I am sticking with my favorite from now on, and highly recommend this brand!

Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

 
3.0

An affordable, quality product

By 

from East Troy, WI

Comments about CoverGirl Professional Super Thick Lash Mascara:

Cover Girl's Professional Super Thick Lash is my most recent beauty buy.  I prefer super thick-looking lashes, and the product does accomplish that.  I tend to have problems with mascara being runny and creating "raccoon eyes", but this one does, for the most part, stay on my lashes and off my skin.  Although it is a little runny at times, it's minimal compared with other brands of mascara I've tried in the past (such as Maybeline).  Also, I haven't had any issues with CG Professional Super Thick lash flaking off, nor have I experienced any eye irritations.  Overall, I'm quite satisfied with this product. 

Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

 
5.0

I swear by CoverGirl Super Thick Lash Mascara!

By 

from Twain Harte, CA

Comments about CoverGirl Professional Super Thick Lash Mascara:

I have used Covergirl Professional Super Thick Lash Mascara ever since I was a teenager.  In 1968, I was so thrilled, my mom let me start wearing mascara, and this is the one she bought for me.Over the years I tried to switch once only because the store was out of my color.  And I opted for another brand. I didnt like it and couldnt wait till the new shipment came in!

    A few years back when the company decided to change the packaging, I was concerned the the product would change to.  If they did do some changes to the product, it didnt affect it at all.

I like it because the color I use, being very black goes on with out clumping.  I like the design of the mascara want, it seperates my lashes and covers them completly.I also like the way the tip is designed.  It hold just enough mascara on it for me to glide the tip across the bottom lashes form side to side, instead of combing them on like  I do the top ones.  I've tried this with the other brand I had to use and I had huge clumps on the bottom lashes.

I have never had flaking or smudging.  I like the idea that it comes off with just soap and water.  Or if it gets wet while swimming, I just use a tissue under my eyes and it's clean. With 7 children and grandchildren being born, theres lots of tears at birthing time,  But when there are tears I dont look like a raccoon, I just wipe under my eyes and all ready to renew my mascara again!

I am 57 years old now and still usin this mascara, I dont even change to another kind of mascara with in the same brand name.  My three daughters also use this same mascara, they will change from time to time, but always come back to this one.

One of them ocmmented the other day that when she uses this mascara, she doesnt have to use a sharp object to seperate her lashes.  (GOOD!) :)

 

Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

 
5.0

Super Thick Mascasra - love it!

By 

from Manassas, VA

Comments about CoverGirl Professional Super Thick Lash Mascara:

I've had this mascara for years - it my favorite, "go to" brand of mascara. I love that it's available just above anyway, including drugstores, walmart, target, etc. It's always under eight bucks and sometimes, I can get it on sale or use a coupon.

 

I originally picked it up because Real Simple said they had good results with it in test runs. It was within my price range, so I decided to try it. I'm so glad I did!

It's smooth and defining - I'd say those were it's main characteristics. It's not as much voluminizing, if that's what you're looking for, but I wasn't. It also helps lengthen my lashes, and of course, I like that.

Another pro is that it washes away easily. I got the waterproof bottle by mistake and of course, that requires something more than soap and water. However, the regular bottle doesn't require makeup remover. I like the regular kind.

All in all, this is a good simple mascara I will keep using.

 

 

Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

Displaying reviews 1-10

Back to top

Previous | Next »