CoverGirl Fantastic Lash

CoverGirl Fantastic Lash Reviews



Overall 4 star rating3.92 of 5 (by 13 users)



CoverGirl Fantastic Lash Review Summary

Our beauty divas are torn as to whether CoverGirl Fantastic Lash Mascarais a great mascara or a decent one that flakes a lot. Its fans say that CoverGirl Fantastic Lash Mascara is a great daytime mascara because it looks very natural and can be amped up with a couple of more coats for nighttime. They say they get longer, thicker lashes and the mascara never smears. Other reviewers, however, say that none of that matters since CoverGirl Fantastic Lash Mascara flakes terribly. Rapunzel says, "While it does not smear, it flakes horribly." They say flecks land on their faces and under their eyes all day long and is even worse when they try to remove it at night. While they do say that the mascara gives their lashes color and length, the flaking makes it a no go for them. Comparing mascaras? We have reviews of all brands and formulas for you to read.
46% of people rated CoverGirl Fantastic Lash as 5 stars
46% of people rated CoverGirl Fantastic Lash as 5 stars%
46%
23% of people rated CoverGirl Fantastic Lash as 4 stars
23% of people rated CoverGirl Fantastic Lash as 4 stars%
23%
15% of people rated CoverGirl Fantastic Lash as 3 stars
15% of people rated CoverGirl Fantastic Lash as 3 stars%
15%
8% of people rated CoverGirl Fantastic Lash as 2 stars
8% of people rated CoverGirl Fantastic Lash as 2 stars%
8%
8% of people rated CoverGirl Fantastic Lash as 1 star
8% of people rated CoverGirl Fantastic Lash as 1 star%
8%
69% 69% of people recommend CoverGirl Fantastic Lash 31% of people don't recommend CoverGirl Fantastic Lash 31%
 

CoverGirl Fantastic Lash Comparison

5 star rating Most Helpful
Favorable Review
DEC
13
2007

I was very surprised with this product.  Large brush that curls your lashes as you  use the product.  During the day about 2 swipes makes a natural looking eye.   The for evening add another 2-3 swipes to thicken it up.

I use Revlon makeup remover towels to clean my face before bed.  So no trouble...

review »
2009 Advisor
into natural looking cosmetics, a beauty diva

MacGyver
Cleveland, OH
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
3 star rating Most Helpful
Critical Review
JAN
24
2008
I bought the cover girl fantastic lash when my last mascera ran out. I was debating between this one and the telascopic, and chose this one being it was on high reccomendation by the store assistant. I didn't really care for it though. I feel like it takes me many coats to achive the look that I want,... review »
reviewer
diva-in-training, a beauty diva

rockstar777
New York, NY
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 

CoverGirl Fantastic Lash Ratings and Reviews

items/page: 15 | 30 | 50 displaying 1 to 11 of 13 sort by: most helpful | date | rating


1
helpful
vote
wearing makeup daily, a woman, on a budget, smart shopper, loving this product

DEC
13
2007
I'm always looking to find better mascara and I finally stumbled across something that's better than the rest!  I have very fair skin as well as white eyelashes and eybrows (I was born a "toehead"), so it's very hard to find a product that colors my lashes to add emphasis to my eyes without looking too fake or cakey (I have to apply from root to tip, not just the tip).  After a friend suggested I try it, I bought it and tested it out immediately by hitting the gym, then hitting the pool right afterwards.  I was worried I might look like a raccoon after those activities, but upon checking myself... review »
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
5 star rating
reviewer
SensibleAura333
Battle Creek, MI



1
helpful
vote
Value Conscious, a beauty diva, desire a natural look, mom of 2

AUG
1
2008

I had heard good things about the CoverGirl Fantastic Lash mascara, so I was decided to try it.  I agree with the other reviewers that it doesn't smear.  I have even walked out in the rain and come in without the racoon look.  My lashes are defined, don't clump, and look beautiful.  At least in the morning.

While it does not smear, it flakes horribly.  At least once every two weeks, I have to take a contact out and wash out a mascara clump from my eye.  By the end of the day I have a fine black look underneath one or both eyes.  Also, my standard eyemakeup remover doesn't remove it and...

review »
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
2 star rating
reviewer
Rapunzal
Waldron, IN



1
helpful
vote
a cosmetics junkie

NOV
26
2008

I have always been trying different mascaras to find the "perfect" one and i guess the search continues! When I applied this product, it clumps easily and when it dries it is very flakey. but the worst is when im washing my face and trying to get the stuff off!  i find flakes all over my face and they get into my eyes. they get very irrated and red and feel like they are scratched.

 I would NEVER recommend this product to ANYONE!!!


Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
1 star rating
reviewer
jltchase2003
Marrero, LA



1
helpful
vote
a cosmetics junkie, very happy with this product

AUG
21
2007
I use this mascara almost everyday! I apply it using a plastic card after I curl my eyelashes and it's perfect! The brush separates my lashes like a fan. I love this product. Plus, after I hot the steam room, it does not smear! Many of my friends ask how I can have such nice lashes after a day at the gym and I always recommend this product.
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
5 star rating
reviewer
kittieface
Los Angeles, CA



1
helpful
vote

Rated on November 19, 2008

Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
5 star rating
melissacrawford
Fort Dick, CA



D
a mascara lover, into trying new things, fun loving, always trying new stuff, practical, a bargain hunter

OCT
9
2009

Cover Girl fantastic lash with hydrofuge is a great waterproof mascara.  I wear contacts, so waterproof mascara isn't exactly the best thing for me to be using, but this product (when kept away from my contacts) works well.  It plumps up my lashes and makes them feel full and thick.  I have a hard time removing this product with my eye makeup remover, which is oil-free.  I may need to purchase an oil based remover or switch to a non-waterproof mascara.  The packaging is sophisticated and works well with the Cover Girl brand.  This product helps shape my eyelashes, so that they stay curled...

review »
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
4 star rating
2009 Writer
paigebaum
Saint Paul, MN



D
a beauty diva, loving this product, a bargain hunter

SEP
27
2009

While I was at rite aid picking up a few toiletries I stumbled across this mascara with a sign on top labeled $1.97. At first I wondered why it was so cheap considering the fact that it was about 6 or 7 dollars a few weeks ago. I checked the packaging and it was never opened, great deals don't come often for mascara so I went ahead and bought it. The next day I tried it I was so surprised to see my new lashes. I am calling them my new lashes because I have never seen them that curvy and up there before. I was so shocked, I fell in love with this mascara! I put aside all my expensive mascara to...

review »
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
4 star rating
2009 Writer
kingbaby1032
Sunnyvale, CA



D
take care of my skin, wearing makeup daily, very skin conscious

NOV
29
2007
I just love this mascara. Once I put it on, I don't have to worry about it smearing. I can go swimming, and work out and sweat and it doesn't run down my face. I can even cry and it doesn't smear. I like that it doesn't cost alot and that I can get it at places like Walmart. But it does take an oil based mascara remover to get it off.
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
5 star rating
reviewer
bobsterfolsom
Mayo, FL



D
a beauty diva, a cosmetics junkie, troubled by acne, au 'naturale', keeping my skin clear

AUG
2
2008
Cover girl fantastic lash is good if you use it for a short period of time. However, if u use it from morning to night, chances are you will get raccoon eyes. I love it because it's waterproof and it doesn't smear,  but it does give you that raccoon look if u wear it for too long. It smells bad too :(
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
3 star rating
reviewer
anakisenk123
Pleasant Hill, CA



D

FEB
7
2008

I really liked this stuff, but one day I went to put it on and I pulled out just the stick. The brush had come off in the mascara! Grrrrrr.......

note to anyone:don't used after it has been frozen, or, just don't accidently leave it in your car after a snow storm :-D


Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
4 star rating
reviewer
longblondie
Ames, IA



D
diva-in-training

OCT
9
2008
i love cover girl fantastic lash in brown and black with the curved brush. it makes my lashes look so long. i even like that the bottle is red. perfect.
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
5 star rating
reviewer
kustuck
Martinez, CA



Reviews of CoverGirl Fantastic Lash


Start a New Discussion about CoverGirl Fantastic Lash