Cookie

Cookie Review



Overall 3.00 of 5 view all 14 reviews
 




reviewer
giraffe454
Farmington, MN
Short read if you can find the 5 pages of articles in the ads
2 star rating

magazine subscriber, suburban parent, value conscious, an avid reader
Pros

    short read

Cons
    More ads then stories, Geared toward upper income moms

FEB
23
2008

Cookie  — 

I pitched in the $13 for the first year to be a "charter subscriber" to this "new, hip" magazine. The "free bag" drew me in as well as the claim for "new, upscale information". The bag was the cheapest free magazine gift I ever recieved, a tiny piece of nylon crap. Humorous when the magazine touts such expensive, high quality products. I figured the magazine would be something different than the usual "Parents" and "Parenting" magazines I'm always reading. I was very dissappointed in how little information was actually in this magazine. I am estimating there was maybe 30 pages of articles and information in about 150 pages of magazine, and thats estimating high for the useful pages. Nearly the entire magazine was filled with extremely overpriced products and clothing for kids. And even their "affordable" vacations were always in the multiple thousand dollar price range. I loved that every suggested vacation came complete with on site daycare. Why not just leave the kids at home if you don't want to be with them on the vacation. Made no sense to me. The only part of this magazine I enjoyed were the 4 or five Cookie Facts scattered through the first section of the magazine, and they were not worth the subscription price. I can't believe anyone would find this magazine useful. On the positive side, since there were only about 4 articles in the entire magazine, it took only about 5-10 minutes to page through it and read the supposedly good stuff. This magazine might be good for people with unlimited income and a need to keep up with the Joneses, but it's not for the average American family living on any type of a budget. Don't waste your money on this magazine. Oh, one other kind of cute feature, they always ended the magazine with a picture and a story behind it. Kind of cute and sentimental, kind of cheesy, but sadly, one of the highlights for me. Once again, doesn't say much for the magazine's quality.  

Last edited on Feb 23, 2008



I_thumb_down Cookie is not recommended by giraffe454

5
helpful
votes
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
 




I_comment_shdw24 Comments about giraffe454’s Review

 


LovelySmurfette wrote on Mar 20, 2009 at 6:09PM

Yeah, I know what you're saying... I happened to me. And I'm with you about the bag: hell, they promote extremely expensive diaper bags (almost $1000 for a bag to hang the poopy diaper you had to change while you were away from home ???) to go with "fashion" and theirs look like a bag you can get at the family dollar stores. What did these people think when they came out with the idea of this magazine??? Did they just thought in millionaire people? And if it's so, what the hell makes them think that I'm one of them for offered me a subscription??? I need to live from a budget!!!

EllasMommy wrote on Oct 5, 2008 at 12:36PM

I totally agree. I did the same thing with the subscription and the bag. I really hate this mag and don't get too much from it. Parents and American Baby are much more helpful and pratical. I don't knwo about you, but I'm not about to spend $300 on a play dress for my one year old! Advice - don't waste your money on this mag is you are the "normal" middle class working mom. It's for the New Yorkers....