2009 VIP
AnnaBanana
Oak Park, IL

Ya gotta watch that fine print!

3 star rating

into trying new things, health conscious, crazy about soup, all for kitchen speed and convenience
Pros

    good source of protein and Vitamin A, great lunch or supper for a cold day, Delicious as far as canned soup goes, convenient to carry and prepare

Cons
    WAY too salty, a bit bland, container cannot be recycled

OCT
31
2009

I have fallen into the habit of making my soup which means that I pretty much know what goes into what I have been eating.  Perhaps this is why I got a little careless about label information.  At any rate, I haven't totally given up on commercially prepared and canned soups and had become interested in the new Campbell soups I had been hearing about.  When Peapod put them on sale for $1.67 each, I went for them faster than a dog lunging for a Pupperoni snack.  In my haste and exuberance, I didn't even spare a glance at the nutritional information which Peapod conscientiously posts for all the products they sell. 

Yesterday for lunch I tried Campbell's Select Harvest Chicken with Egg Noodles Soup.  With no small difficulty, I pried the metal lid back, replaced the plastic cover, and microwaved for two popping, banging minutes.  I don't know what other eager soup-eaters' experience has been like, but I enjoyed this soup.  In my bowl at least, there were impressive chunks of carrots, celery, chicken white meat and nice densely textured egg noodles which weren't soggy as they usually are in canned soup.  My cup ranneth over with delicious ingredients and just enough broth to hold them all together.  Although it seemed a tad bland to me, I figured this was a good sign -- in fact, I was so confident that I was eating something healthy that after I was done, I wouldn't have looked at the label information at all if I hadn't been ready to do this review.  OH BOY!

STATS:

Most important here is that Campbell's wants us to believe that one of these bowls contains TWO servings.  That may technically be true -- I think that two cups would fit in a 15 oz. microwave container -- but let's be realistic.  Most people are going to want to eat the whole bowl and not save the rest for later or share with a friend.  So I'm going to share the stats for the whole container.  Each microwaveable soup bowl contains 240 calories with 80 calories from fat.  There are 8 grams Total Fat, 2 grams Saturated Fat, zero Trans Fat, 50 mg. Cholesterol, 960 mg. Sodium, 24 grams Total Carbs, 2 grams Dietary Fiber, 4 grams Sugars, and 16 grams Protein in addition to a very respectable 80% (D.V.) Vitamin A and 4% Calcium. 

Most of this is actually okay.  This soup that I ate at 11 a.m. for "brunch" was enough to satisfy me until 6:30 p.m.  Campbell's Select Harvest Chicken with Egg Noodles Soup does the job that soup like this was invented for centuries ago -- 240 calories isn't actually bad for such a substantial meal that really delivers in the protein and Vitamin A departments.  A bowl of this kind of thing can make a big difference on one of those frosty winter days which will be here soon. 

My outrage here is with the SODIUM which is 40% of an average adult's daily values.  There is just no reason that this soup had to be THAT salty.  Oh yah, and that sea salt you keep hearing about Campbell's using?  Well, according to the label, less than 2% of all this is sea salt which you get along with a massive dose of the REGULAR salt too.

TASTE TIP:

Because Campbell's Select Harvest Chicken with Egg Noodles Soup seemed a little bland to me at first (compared to my experience with homemade soups), I added a couple good shakes of coarse ground black pepper which served to enhance the taste of the soup's ingredients.  (Whatever you do, don't add more SALT!)

 

 

Last edited on Oct 31, 2009



I_thumb_down Campbell's Select Harvest Chicken w/Egg Noodles Soup is not recommended by AnnaBanana

3
helpful
votes
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 




I_comment_shdw24 Comments about AnnaBanana’s Review

 


LoveisJoy wrote on Nov 7, 2009 at 6:30PM

In response to AnnaBanana's comment from Nov 7, 2009 at 3:14PM:

LOL...That's the problem with not writing a complete sentence. Yep, I'll avoid the soup in the future, but I'd better start reading the fine print! :)

AnnaBanana wrote on Nov 7, 2009 at 3:14PM

In response to LoveisJoy's comment from Nov 7, 2009 at 9:46AM:

That was funny, for a minute I thought you meant that you would avoid the fine print in the future! Sometimes I think that's what we should all start doing! I hate to admit it but I had bought two of these things and I just couldn't resist eating the other one a couple days later! That's okay, I just cut back on sodium for the rest of the day!

How's my buddy doing, and of course Persia? I always think cats are so appreciative of love and care and I bet she relishes having such a good safe home now that the season is turning cooler. Today was sure nice though.

Take care! It's always so nice to hear from you.

LoveisJoy wrote on Nov 7, 2009 at 9:46AM

Too bad about the sodium content because I did like this soup. I didn't read the fine print, though. Will avoid it in the future. Thanks for the review. :)

this2shallpass19 wrote on Oct 31, 2009 at 2:16PM

Nice review!