I had almost the same problem and I started using the Shiseido line all their products are alcohol free, that is what was causing the dry tight feeling ater washing, I would recommend the Skincare line but they do have different lines for different problems, the product never made m face oily and i noticed a difference in my pores, they have this one product called skin softner it feels great and you put it on after you wah your face and right before you moisturize it helps the moisturizer sink into your skin instead of sitting on top.  Good Luck