2009 VIP
GigiandAdonai
Luvs2Dance, SC

Not much to this pot pie. Hmm...perhaps a 'flop' pie.

3 star rating

a casual cook, quick and easy, health conscious, will pay for quality, very picky eater

NOV
3
2008
This was my 3-in-1 meal today.  That would be all calories for breakfast, lunch and dinner.  So, to those who read this and say it isn't very healthy or nutritional, I agree.  But in my defense it was all I ate all day so I could take in more sodium, carbs, and cholesterol.

Once cooler weather arrives I love pot pies.  For me, being single, it is an answer to the question: "What shall I have for dinner?"  A pot-pie gives me meat, veggies, and bread all in one.  Banquet brand pot-pies aren't the greatest but aside from a store brand they are probably the cheapest.  I think I pay about 89 or 99 cents for them and they come in a variety of flavors.  The one I ate this evening was Chicken & Broccoli.  They also have a good shelf life.  The one I had tonight was left from last winter.  The box said it was produced after 10/26/07 and best if used by May 14/2009.

Banquet potpies aren't as big as the competitors' let's say Stouffers or Marie Callender's. 

These pot-pies don't produce a flaky crust when baked.  Once you go to pop the top it sort of just caves in and becomes like mush.  I prefer the Marie Callender's and will do a review on those once I get some more!  Another downside with the Banquet is that they use bits and pieces of chicken; which appeared to be dark meat.  I don't like dark meat-I only like the chicken breast.  The vegetables are miniscule compared to those in other brands.  The picture on the box said, "Enlarged to show detail."  Well, I should have had a magnifying glass to look into my bowl because you could barely see the vegetables.  I knew there was broccoli and carrots because I could see some chunks of green and orange. 

It was enough to satisfy my appetite because I didn't have a craving for anything special.  I just knew I needed to eat at some point and this seemed to serve the purpose.  One good thing came about with me choosing a pot-pie.  Since I chose to bake mine I was able to leave the oven door open after it finished baking and it produced a little more heat in the house while the oven was cooling off.

Nutrition Facts for 1 pie (198g):

  • Calories: 350/180 from fat
  • Total Fat: 20g
  • Saturated Fat: 9g
  • Trans Fat: 0
  • Cholesterol: 30mg
  • Sodium: 800mg (whew!)
  • Total Carbs: 32g
  • Dietary Fiber: 2g
  • Sugars: 4g
  • Protein: 10g

If you want something cheap then this may be for you but if you want something good, you should pass.

I'm giving it a 3 because I know I have tasted worse things than this and obviously I like them enough because I buy them year after year when I don't want to fork out more for the Marie Callender's. 

I am now in tears as I was reading the back of the box.  I have never paid attention to the cooking instructions except to get the correct temperature setting for the oven (400 F) and baking time (30-42 minutes).  But I just realized that it said "Check to be sure the pot pie is cooked thoroughly.  Internal temperature needs to reach 165 F as measured by a food thermometer in several spots." 

Now that's deep!  I have never used a cooking thermometer for a pot-pie.  I don't even own one.  I would hope that after mass producing these things they would get the directions right and we wouldn't have to second guess whether or not it's fully cooked.  Do you think that's why mine always caves in?  Should I go buy a food thermometer so I can be better prepared next time?

Last edited on Nov 03, 2008



I_thumb_up Banquet Chicken & Broccoli Pot Pie is recommended by GigiandAdonai

13
helpful
votes
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 




I_comment_shdw24 Comments about GigiandAdonai’s Review

 


CyndiA wrote on Jan 18, 2009 at 8:02PM

Haha! Love that title. I have had some flop pies and other flop quick dinners.

PattyTherre wrote on Nov 13, 2008 at 11:23PM

In response to GigiandAdonai's comment from Nov 13, 2008 at 8:39AM:

Yes, thank God for having your mom in any manner. I wish mine were here. I would gladly take care of her. But there were other plans for her apparently.

GigiandAdonai wrote on Nov 13, 2008 at 8:39AM

In response to PattyTherre's comment from Nov 13, 2008 at 1:39AM:

My mother had a stroke 5 yrs. ago and is now totally dependent on my Dad. I miss her cooking also; especially her meatloaf and chicken-n-dumplin's. But hey, at least I still have my mother with me. ~Gigi

PattyTherre wrote on Nov 13, 2008 at 1:39AM

My mother used to make the best home made pot pies. I so miss her cooking.

GEEBEE wrote on Nov 10, 2008 at 5:34AM

I agree. I just had one the other night. I was very disappointed. I usually get the Marie Callender, but trying to economize, I went with the least expensive. This was more juice than substance. As happens most of the time, you get what you pay for.

writersquill wrote on Nov 9, 2008 at 11:50AM

A thermometer for cooking a pot pie? Good grief! I agree with you--Marie Callendar's makes a wonderful and flaky pot pie and they are so big! You get your money's worth. I like eating them when the children are in school. ~Anna

AnnaBanana wrote on Nov 8, 2008 at 2:15AM

I never bother with a thermometer. You can usually tell if it's done. Boy does this bring back memories. I've eaten my share of Banquet Pot Pies in the old days!

AmyA wrote on Nov 4, 2008 at 7:45PM

These do have a good crust and they aren't to bad if you add a little shredded cheddar cheese when they come out and you open them up :)

Meri wrote on Nov 4, 2008 at 11:42AM

Not my favorite thing to eat.

jasyjen wrote on Nov 4, 2008 at 10:43AM

Great review. The crust is the best part of this "pie" to me.