2009 VIP
Katrena
Piedmont, NC
Skin So Soft Bug Guard Plus is an average product for me
3 star rating

a mosquito magnet, a busy mom
Pros

    Nice idea to combine sunscreen/bug guard, Nice, light fragrance, Dermatologist tested

Cons
    not a great bug guard, Not waterproof, Pricey, Feels oily on skin, CDC doesn't recommend combo product

AUG
4
2008
 

Avon Skin So Soft Bug Guard Plus - Gentle Breeze — 

Avon Skin So Soft Bug Guard Plus has provided average protection for my family. I think the idea of combining a sunscreen with bug protection is great. My kids and I are very fair skinned and tend to attract lots of mosquitoes. It is a welcome relief to apply one rather than two products. However, one website did not recommend using a combined product such as this for children.

I purchased the white lotion variety of this product at a 50% off deal. At 50% off, it was about the same price as another manufacturer's bug spray without sunscreen that we purchased as well.

According to one website that tested numerous types of bug repellents, Avon Skin So Soft Bug Guard Plus provided 23 minutes of complete bug protection, with Skin So Soft bug guard (10 minutes) and Skin So Soft moisturizing sun care (3 minutes) not fairing nearly as well. The longest lasting repellent provided 302 minutes of complete protection according to that website, but this product ranked fifth best, and much better than the least effective product that only provided 0.2 minutes of protection. It appears that high levels of DEET and soy oil were more effective than the IR3535 that is found in Avon Skin So Soft Bug Guard Plus. Oils of various herbs, citronella, and low levels of DEET seemed to provide less complete protection than this product.

Personally, I found Avon Skin So Soft Bug Guard Plus to feel a bit oily when I applied it to my skin. I did not notice any stains on my clothing after using it. Because I had seen the above information in a website, I did not use this product when planning to be out all day. I tend to be a mosquito magnet. Everyone else can be sitting outside enjoying a nice chat while I'm busy swatting and swelling because I have about 100 mosquito welts on me in about 30 minutes. After using this product, I probably got less bites than I would have normally, but I still got mosquito bites after less than 30 minutes outside. However, I did not get sunburned.

My Viewpoint:

I'm recommending this product only for short periods of time outside. Its ingredient seems to be safer for children than DEET, and the sunscreen is a definite plus. If planning to be outside for more than 20-25 minutes or if you are a mosquito magnet or planning to be in an area with high mosquito counts, I would go with another product such as Cutter Advanced Sport.

UPDATE:

I just read some information and discovered that the Center for Disease Control (CDC) does not recommend products that are intended to repel mosquitoes that are mixed with sunscreen. The thinking is that sunscreens are designed for freuent use throughout the day to provide maximum protection, while they recommend for safety reasons that mosquito repellents, especially those containing DEET (which this one doesn't contain DEET), should be used sparingly.

Last edited on Aug 31, 2008



I_thumb_up Avon Skin So Soft Bug Guard Plus - Gentle Breeze is recommended by Katrena

3
helpful
votes
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
 




I_comment_shdw24 Comments about Katrena’s Review

 


Katrena wrote on Aug 5, 2008 at 10:23PM

In response to joyjoy's comment from Aug 5, 2008 at 6:01PM:

I hadn't heard that it was supposed to help with itching--thanks for the tip. A lot of the mosquito repellent literature that I've studied recommends only using a minimum amount of the product only applied to areas of the skin that are exposed (while avoiding applying to hands and faces of children), so I'm not real sure about putting it in the bath water due to safety reasons. Of course I'd probably want to take a bath in anything that would definitely keep the mosquitoes away from me.

joyjoy wrote on Aug 5, 2008 at 6:01PM

Here are a couple of tips that Avon doesn't advertise. If you get bitten by a mosquito (or any other insect that causes itching) rub Skin-So-Soft bath oil on the bite, it will stop the itch in seconds. Put the bath oil in your children's bath water and it will keep mosquitoes away.