At the Movies

At the Movies Review



Overall 1.00 of 5 (by 1 user)
 




2008 Advisor
jmdobies
Austin, TX

Thumbs Down: Gene Siskel Must Be Turning Over in His Grave

1 star rating

Open-minded, into Independent Films, waiting for the DVD, forty something, Blogger, on vitamins, Lover of quirky, unique films, somebody's sibling
show all »
Pros

    None That I Can Think Of

Cons
    Ben Lyons is a Total Douche

DEC
29
2008
 
 

Roger Ebert and Gene Siskel pioneered the idea of the movie review show on their long-running television series "At the Movies," with their trademark "Thumbs Up, Thumbs Down." After Siskel's death, Chicago Tribune film critic Richard Roeper took the seat across the aisle from Ebert, and when Ebert lost his voice in the wake of cancer surgery, a series of guest reviewers took his place.

In 2008, the Disney Company, who owned the rights to the show, announced that Ebert and Roeper were being replaced by Turner Classic Movies host Ben Mankiewicz and the twentysomething Ben Lyons, from "E! News Daily" and Nickelodeon's "My Family's Got Guts."

Roger Ebert took the "Thumbs" with him, as he and Siskel's estate own the trademark.

While Mankiewicz gets a pass, for his Hollywood pedigree and TCM gig (even though he's no Robert Osborne), Lyons is clearly in over his head. The son of hack film critic Jeffrey Lyons, he is living proof that the apple does not fall far from the tree. This jejeune putz is not just a lousy reviewer, he also comes off as a total douche. Even the horrible Michael Medved would have been preferrable to this tool, and that's saying something. But Disney clearly wasn't looking for insightful criticism here. They were hoping that Lyons would attract the much-coveted 18 to 25 demographic, even though that audience doesn't give a rat's ass about film criticism.

Then again, with the vast majority of modern Hollywood movies being disposable crap, maybe Lyons was the perfect choice for the job.

"At the Movies" is syndicated. Check local listings for time and station, then watch something else.

Last edited on Dec 30, 2008



I_thumb_down At the Movies is not recommended by jmdobies

3
helpful
votes
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 




I_comment_shdw24 Comments about jmdobies’s Review

 


bkovacs wrote on Dec 31, 2008 at 8:26AM

Siskel and Ebert actually started this format on PBS with a program called "Sneak Previews," which is where they started their trademarked thumbs up/down. It ran for several years, then they switched to a syndicated show produced by TV station WTTG. When they both refused to renew their contracts with WTTG/Tribune in 1982, they went to Disney. However, PBS retained the rights to the show "Sneak Previews," so S&E changed the title to "At the Movies."

I haven't seen this new show, but "At the Movies" without either Siskel or Ebert just isn't worth watching. Thanks for the review!

--Bob