Autos Baby Beauty Books Computers Education Electronics Health Home & Garden Local Places Movies Pets Travel Web Sites more…
Apple MacBook Pro Notebook

Apple MacBook Pro Notebook Review



Overall 4.68 of 5 view all 112 reviews



Best laptop on the market
4 star rating

heavy Adobe app user, UI nitpicker, computer geek, creative professional
Pros

    excellent OS, great screen, good keyboard, solid build, stylish design

Cons
    battery life short, no HD activity light, runs a bit hot, no dock

JAN
17
2007

After using MS Windows for over 15 years, I switched to a Mac—and I'm not going back. OSX is fantastic. The MacBook Pro comes with a host of extras: lit keyboard, built in video camera, video card that can drive a 30" display, fast processor, and easily upgradable memory. The 15" form factor is pretty much perfect for a work laptop - just enough screen real estate for screen hog programs such as Dreamweaver or Photoshop but small enough not to be bulky to carry around (I think the 17" Macbook Pro tips the scale on the too bulky side).

The glide pad is the best of any laptop computer I've used (IBM ThinkPad T41, Dell Latitude, Toshiba Satellite). One worry that I had was losing the use of the right mouse button (I use it all the time!)—well it was an unfounded fear. Turns out with the new trackpads, putting two fingers down on the pad and then clicking the large single button gets you your right click - it is much more intuitive and natural than choosing which button to click when you have two to choose from. Furthermore, moving two fingers on the glide pad will scroll whatever window you are in—no more mousing over to the scroll bar! When I started using the MacBook Pro, I was also using a Dell Latitude laptop, and found it very frustrating when upon returning to the Dell I couldn't scroll with my two fingers on the glide pad. As a side note, the IBM ThinkPad had a third button (between the left and right mouse buttons by the glide pad) which you could hold down to scroll with one finger on the glide pad. I found this was better than not having a scrolling option (as on the Dell), but more often than not it felt like a game of Twister with your fingers - the MacBook two finger solution is far superior!

Moving on to the keyboard—it has a very good feel to it. I would put it on par with the IBM ThinkPad keyboard that had been my favourite to this point. Where the MacBook Pro surpasses the IBM is in the backlighting. The backlighting is adjustable—for that matter it will automatically adjust to best match the ambient light (or lack of it). This is a much better solution than the keyboard light that was housed at the top of the ThinkPad screen. The ThinkPad's light's intensity was not adjustable and would case glare when looking at the screen.

The 15" screen on the MacBook Pro is exquisite—the best screen that I've used on any laptop. Being a creative professional, colour fidelity, contrast and image brightness are of paramount importance and the MacBook Pro does not disappoint. I have grown accustomed to the wide aspect ratio of the screen so much so that my external monitor had to be a wide aspect ratio as well (I currently use a Dell 20" monitor—Model #2007WFP).

The Bluetooth connectivity is also superb. I use a bluetooth mouse and keyboard in addition to my phone. I have yet to encounter any problems with any of the devices maintaining their connection to the Macbook. On the the WiFi end of things, 802.11g works great. Also make sure you max out your memory (I have 2GB and wouldn't mind a gig or two more) if you are using the Adobe Creative Suite

There are several improvements that could be made to the MacBook Pro:

  • add a FireWire 800 port (that now exists on the latest version)
  • add a harddrive activity light
  • increase battery life (I get an average of 2.5 hours on a charge)
  • create a dock (having to plug in 5 cords every morning when I arrive at work is not ideal)
  • support more than 2GB of RAM (on the latest version you can install up to 3GB)

One final observation, the overall integration of programs is far superior on OSX when compared to Windows XP. The mac is less a collection of disparate apps and more of a computing environment. There seems to be more thought put into usability and integration on a Mac than a Windows machine. More often than not, less is more on a Mac. Less stress and more enjoyment. Less useless bells & whistles and more focus on getting things done. Less repetitive entry of data and more integration.

Having intensively used the Microsoft platform (staring with DOS back in the good old days) for more than two decades, and now having used a Mac for 5 months, I have reached a simple conclusion...

Do yourself a favour—get a Mac.

 

Last edited on Apr 03, 2007


I_thumb_up Apple MacBook Pro Notebook is recommended by vytas


10
helpful
votes
Did you find this review helpful?
Review inappropriate?




I_comment_shdw24 Comments about vytas’s Review



vytas wrote on Nov 28, 2007 at 10:28AM


In response to aprilefisher's comment from Nov 21, 2007 at 2:51PM:

Dreamweaver is probably the best HTML editor out there. I've been using it since version 1 and have never come across anything that even came close to its feature set or ease of use both for the professional coder and a beginner.


aprilefisher wrote on Nov 21, 2007 at 2:51PM


In response to vytas's comment from Nov 21, 2007 at 2:34PM:

I've heard that InDesign will probably develop to the industry standard because of its, as you say, "superb integration." I've been using Quark for only about 6 months now (for web-based and print documents), and find it remarkably easy (although I realize that different software would probably be more ideal for web documents--Dreamweaver??). I don't own quark but use it at work; however, when I make that ever-so-expensive purchase of several adobe softwares or some adobe software package, I will definitly be sure to fully investigate InDesign first! I'm actually not a web design or print design by trade, but I do a little of it at work and want to do a lot more (because it's so fun) at home. Thanks again -- you are so helpful! And I see that message you left me a message about Amelie up there too--Amelie, to me, is the perfect movie, which I am really, honestly, in love with. I will check out Delicatessen, absolutely--I have a taste for darker movies as well.


vytas wrote on Nov 21, 2007 at 2:34PM


In response to aprilefisher's comment from Nov 21, 2007 at 2:08PM:

I'll look forward to your review of the MacBook Pro. ;-) I noticed you mentioned Quark - you owe it to yourself to try Adobe InDesign - superb integration with Photoshop and Illustrator - along with some great features that Quark is struggling to catch-up and support.


aprilefisher wrote on Nov 21, 2007 at 2:08PM


In response to vytas's comment from Nov 20, 2007 at 12:54PM:

Thanks so much--I was absolutely going to buy glossy too (I have to confess...I just think they're pretty) but I had no idea it effected the color accuracy--which is sooo important, especially since one of the reasons I've been thinking Mac is because I always hear it is better with adobe software like photoshop and quark.


vytas wrote on Nov 20, 2007 at 12:54PM


In response to aprilefisher's comment from Nov 20, 2007 at 12:00PM:

Thanks for the compliment aprilefisher! The MacBook Pros are great machines indeed. I would strongly recommend upgrading the memory to 4GB (the max that is currently supported - great prices for buying DIMMs can be found on www.macsales.com a.k.a. OtherWorldComputing.com) and going with a matte screen (you now have the choice of glossy or matte) - the matte display may not have the pop that a glossy screen has, but for color accurate work , a matte screen is better. Another feature that has been added since I wrote this review is LED backlighting for the screen - longer lasting, lower power requirements and no mercury in the manufacturing of the LEDs. Finally with the latest OSX version (Leopard) running you'll be glad you ditched MS Windows (though if you ever run into a situation that requires Windows, you can always run it under Parallels or VMWare Fusion). Best of luck with your move to Mac.


aprilefisher wrote on Nov 20, 2007 at 12:00PM


Wow, this is a very thorough review! I have been flirting with the idea of going Mac from PC for a while now, especially because I have been dabbling in adobe software. The cost of a Mac concerns me a bit, but the idea of speed and upgradeable memory on the Mac, in addition to the elimination of redundant and unnecessary features of Windows...hmmm...I think I might be sold!


icarus872 wrote on Oct 24, 2007 at 11:42AM


Anyone know when it's going to be rev'd?


andy wrote on Mar 30, 2007 at 11:57PM


I wish I had read this review a long time ago. I would have switched to a Mac sooner. This is a great review!


leon wrote on Feb 27, 2007 at 2:29PM


Couldn't agree more. Best laptop ever.