American Idol

American Idol Reviews



Overall 4 star rating4.10 of 5 (by 39 users)



American Idol Review Summary

If you hate reality shows blame American Idol. If you love reality shows, thank American Idol. While Survivor came first, Idol was bigger. Still immensely popular after 8 seasons, American Idol is a talent competition that appeals to a broad demographic. Some like to live vicariously through the contestants because, "Magic happens when an average person gets a chance at stardom." Some like to judge the competition, "It is fun to see the judges agree on the talents of the singers, but it is even more fun to see the judges disagree." And some just love the music and/or a combination of all three. Finally, "It's a show that anyone can watch and enjoy, and you don't have to worry about foul language or too much sexuality if you have little kids around". The next season of American Idol begins in January on Fox.
49% of people rated American Idol as 5 stars
49% of people rated American Idol as 5 stars%
49%
28% of people rated American Idol as 4 stars
28% of people rated American Idol as 4 stars%
28%
13% of people rated American Idol as 3 stars
13% of people rated American Idol as 3 stars%
13%
5% of people rated American Idol as 2 stars
5% of people rated American Idol as 2 stars%
5%
5% of people rated American Idol as 1 star
5% of people rated American Idol as 1 star%
5%
87% 87% of people recommend American Idol 13% of people don't recommend American Idol 13%
 

American Idol Comparison

5 star rating Most Helpful
Favorable Review
MAY
25
2009

I started watching American Idol the year Fantasia Barrino won, and at first I wasn't really into it.

Now, I'm hooked.

The season starts with auditions that range from comical to breath taking to a little bit creepy. Automatically, you should be able to tell who will go far, and, at a glance, who won'...

read full review »
2009 Writer
Likes to be entertained, a comedy fan

Brittanyls
Westwood, NJ
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
3 star rating Most Helpful
Critical Review
MAR
9
2008
Since I started watching Idol 3 years ago,I became an instant fan of it.What I love most about it is that it gives everybody who has a potential in singing to make it in that field of entertainment.It is also amusing to watch especially on elimination because some people seem to just want to see themselve... read full review »
reviewer 2008 Contributor
into Independent Films, Likes to be entertained

jansky
Lockport, IL
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 

American Idol Ratings and Reviews

items/page: 15 | 30 | 50 displaying 1 to 14 of 39 sort by: most helpful | date | rating


7
helpful
votes
a musician, very picky about tv, a travel junkie

APR
26
2007

Magic happens when an average person gets a chance at stardom
Movies have successfully played upon this theme for years.  Whether your thing is pro golf tours, beauty pageants, Nascar races, Dancing with the Stars, The French Open . . . we all want to see the Wild Card take away the crown.   Each season, CBS's American Idol gives 16 talented singers that chance . . . IF they can prove themselves under enormous pressure.   

Format  of the Show
Following nationwide auditions, a small selected group perform one song live, each week, for the viewing audience.  Power to the people - at the close...

read full review »
5 star rating
2009 Advisor
LibbyMcMillan
Sanibel, FL



3
helpful
votes
a woman, Likes to be entertained, an avid TV watcher, Love Good Clean Entertainment, a music lover, a fan of good music, music fanatic, Music Fan

MAR
30
2009

American Idol to me is the best platform for unknown talent to show what they can do. Even though the judges get on my nerves at times, it still is one of the most entertaining Talent Show on television.

I like the fact that they have guest musicians as the mentors for the new talent. It is just another way you get entertained. I also like the way they have different Musical Genre Week. I think this helps the new talent to stretch their wings!

As far as the judges go, I really like Randy, I like Paula, and I even like Simon, except when he is so mean to people. I do NOT however like the new Kara....

read full review »
5 star rating
2008 Writer
bound4heaven
Shelbyville, IN



Reviews continue below ad
3
helpful
votes
a movie buff, watching with kids, a DVR enthusiast

APR
26
2008
American Idol is one of my favorites shows on TV. I have watched American Idol since season 1 and I will keep watching until it isn't on anymore and I can not imagine American Idol never being on.It is the one thing I look forward to after Christmas b/c I know it starts in January.If you are not familiar with it there are 3 judges Simon Cowell who always speaks his mind no matter what it is,Paula Abdul the "nice" judge but always rambles on,And Randy Jackson who is an in between of the other 2.You watch auditions at the beginning to see who goes to Hollywood so you see the best and the worst of... read full review »
5 star rating
2008 Reviewer
dragonflyyk
Oklahoma City, OK



1
helpful
vote
a movie buff, an infrequent movie goer, comedy fan

APR
15
2009

Does anybody notice that all of a sudden you get 15 mins of show and the rest tv commercial.  I really like the show but this is getting out of control. Last nite there was so many ads I was ready to throw the tv out the window.  One of the few good shows on tv and they have to ruin it tell ya what next year they can count me out becuase i have a life and got better things to do than wacting some dumb ad about a man tryin to get a hard on. hahah  These advertisers have taken over the tv and now are computors and people fall for it it really is sad.  What I say is STOP BUYING THEIR JUNK.  keep...

read full review »
4 star rating
ladygirl79
Coldwater, MI



D
a woman, an avid TV watcher, Likes to be entertained

JAN
5
2008

I never really understood the hype of American Idol until I finally watched an episode.  The episode I watched featured the contestants singing songs from my favorite musician Bon Jovi.  The singers not only did covers of the band's hits, but they put their own unique spin on the rhythm and beat of the songs.  It was amazing.  Each week, the aspiring singers compete for the love of the judges and sing their hearts out for the ultimate prize.  Some weeks they are able to sing their own songs and other weeks they are given a specific singing mentor to sing their hits.  Not only are the contestants...

read full review »
4 star rating
2009 VIP
stef42678
Las Vegas, NV



D
a comedy fan, a sitcom watcher, Every day computer user, Internet User, a woman, Open-minded, an avid TV watcher, comedy fan

DEC
31
2007
I absolutely love watching this show. It has turned into a family get-together type of thing at my house, where we all sit down and watch American Idol together. It's a show that anyone can watch and enjoy, and you don't have to worry about foul language or too much sexuality if you have little kids around. It's fun to guess who you think is going to get booted off each week as well as watch the try-out part of the show. It's a show that anyone can easily get enthralled with, and I can't wait for the next season to start up again in a couple of weeks.
5 star rating
mariposa326
Cold Spring, KY



D

Rated on February 5, 2008

4 star rating
reviewer 2008 Reviewer
Sandsky
Mountain View, WY



D

SEP
25
2009

American Idol has remained on the top of the charts since it began airing several years ago.  Personally I think it is a very entertaining program.  The beginning auditions are unreal.  Thousands come to be a part of the action trying to make it to Hollywood.  The thing I will never understand is how half those contestants got the nerve to audition they must be tone deaf and delusional.  The actual competition is enhanced by the wonderful set of judges all of whom are unique and entertaining.  Paula Abdul will be sadly missed.  She was so supportive and thoughtful in all her comments and...

read full review »
5 star rating
reviewer 2009 Writer
auntcathy
Bloomfield, NJ



D
a reality TV watcher, a fan of clever plots, a comedy fan, a romantic, a parent, a pet owner, a sitcom watcher, a travel junkie

DEC
18
2007
There are people in the world who think that good things only happen to a certain type of people. But when you watch American Idol it shows you that anything can happen, to anyone, at anytime. There are people from all over the world who go and try out for the show. People from big cities, farms and even people who have absolutely no ability to sing at all. It shows you that when you work hard for something (it doesnt' have to be singing) and put your heart into it, you will get a good outcome. In the case of American Idol even if you don't make it to the final round there are millions of people... read full review »
5 star rating
mschris
Peculiar, MO



D

APR
29
2009

American Idol is great.  We have found some really great talent from this show.  I think that this season has some very talented people whereas some of the prior years didn't.  My favorite this year is Adam Lambert.  Not one contestant compares to him.  I have watched every year of idol and look forward to who's going to stay in the competition from week to week.  There have been some years that I thought people were voted out too early, especially in the case of Chris Daugthery.  His voice went right through me.  But I keep watching every year regardless of who has won each year.  We...

read full review »
5 star rating
reviewer 2009 Reviewer
jank1708
Alsip, IL



D
comedy fan, an avid TV watcher, having a sense of humor, TV addict, a woman, a person who enjoys quality

NOV
18
2007
American Idol is the best reality show around.  This show entertains you while finding the best talent out there and letting you watch them get better.  Week after week you can watch great talent grow into even greater talent.  That is after watching the adutions which can be down right hilarious.  I also love to hear what the judges have to say.  When it is all said and done American Idol brings great talent to the eyes and ears of millions of people.  Almost all the contestants in the top 10 usually teriffic.  Year after year I think they found the best but the keep finding great talent... read full review »
5 star rating
reviewer
rebafan651
Johnstown, PA



D
an infrequent movie goer, watching chick flicks, watching with kids, a comedy fan

JAN
16
2008
I love to watch American Idol. It is entertaining. Can't wait to hear what Simon has to say. He can be rude at times but sometimes its true what he says. Like the saying goes the truth hurts but sometimes he can come across as being very obnoxious. There are times where there are people who don't deserve the rudeness. Paula is too nice. Randy cracks me up. He calls it how he sees it. He at least has a heart as Paula does but Simon sometimes seems so heartless. I just can't beleive how some of the people actually get on there thinking they are good singers when they SUCK BIG TIME. Don't they hear... read full review »
4 star rating
reviewer
lovespooh1
Belcamp, MD



D
Likes to be entertained

APR
29
2008
american idol is nothing more than i popularity contest where it isnt even based on talent anymore...it is a complete set up and peoplewith real talent have no chance if there is a pretty person that they are competing against. the last show a talented singer was voted off..however she was the best performance of the night... and david a. completly messed up the last line of the song and changed the way it was song when that week you were not susposed to be able to do that did and didnt get repramended for it at all. it make sme so angry that these talented young people dont even have a chance... read full review »
3 star rating
reviewer
kayky1017
Carolina Beach, NC



D
fun loving, coupon saver

AUG
12
2009

American Idol has created some amazing stars and some of them didn't even finish in the number 1 or number 2 spots.  The beginning when all types of people try out and the ones that are horrible but think they can sing is so funny!!   Kelly Clarkson ws the first to come out of this show and she was an instant success.  Carrie Underwood came along and evryone loved the girl from Oklahoma.  Chris Daughtery has estblished a great career from the show also.  The judges help make it what it is..  I can't wait each year for it to come back on .


5 star rating
vecollins
Columbus, GA



Reviews of American Idol

1  2  3  
Buttons_next
 

Start a New Discussion about American Idol