I got this mascara in black, it is thickening and I like the look of it on my lashes. It stays pretty well through out the day, without flaking which I something I hate. It added nice volume to my lashes and some length too. The only reason I didn't give this product the best rating, is that when I go to take it off, it often leaves a bit of a black ring around my eyes that is difficult to remove. I know i could use an eye makeup remover each night, but that's not really part of my daily routine.