wow! i just flew first class on Alaska last night from SEA to DCA. I was beyond impressed! From the warm mixed nuts to the ice cream sundae, it was a great experience. I don't understand the "no meal" comment. Also, my seat reclined quite nicely!
Upon boarding we were given the customary warm nuts and cocktail. Dinner was a tomatoe and mozarella salad followed by a quite tasty chicken with artichokes and dessert followed an hour or so later with an ice cream sundae with a choice of toppings. Our flight steward was awesome and went out of his way to make sure we were comfortable at all times. I was impressed that he called everyone by name and was beyond friendly and polite.
With my experience, I don't understand the negative comments about Alaska Air first class. My only possible complaint would be the digEplayers. But that is only because I wasn't interested in the many selections offered. I just couldn't find anything to hold my interest.