Autos Baby Beauty Books Computers Education Electronics Health Home & Garden Local Places Movies Pets Travel Web Sites more…

A Prairie Home Companion

A Prairie Home Companion Reviews



Overall 2.5 star rating2.62 of 5 (by 8 users)




A Prairie Home Companion Review Summary

A small selection of viewers feel that A Prairie Home Companion is "a warm Altman tribute to the passing of time and styles." However, the majority of reviewers find "the radio broadcast is boring; why would the movie be different?" Robert Altman directs this film version of Garrison Keillor's NPR radio show of the same name, starring Keillor as himself. He "has done wonders with ensemble casts, but this is not one of his exemplary works," such as The Long Goodbye and M*A*S*H. Most feel with names like Woody Harrelson, Tommy Lee Jones, Kevin Kline, Lindsay Lohan, Virginia Madsen, and Meryl Streep, it makes A Prairie Home Companion a "great cast ... bad movie."
25% of people rated A Prairie Home Companion  as 5 stars
25% of people rated A Prairie Home Companion  as 5 stars%
25%
No one rated A Prairie Home Companion  as 4 stars
No one rated A Prairie Home Companion  as 4 stars%
0%
14% of people rated A Prairie Home Companion  as 3 stars
14% of people rated A Prairie Home Companion  as 3 stars%
14%
38% of people rated A Prairie Home Companion  as 2 stars
38% of people rated A Prairie Home Companion  as 2 stars%
38%
25% of people rated A Prairie Home Companion  as 1 star
25% of people rated A Prairie Home Companion  as 1 star%
25%
25% 25% of people recommend A Prairie Home Companion 75% of people don't recommend A Prairie Home Companion 75%

A Prairie Home Companion Comparison

5 star rating Most Helpful
Favorable Review
JUL
1
2007
I like Robert Altman, but not every movie he's ever made. — I am not a big fan of the radio show--though I guess you could say I respect it and appreciate the tradition Garrison and others are continueing. — I do not like Country Music. — As the move went into production-- and I… read full review »
a movie guru, a lover of quirky unique films

ChrisJarmick
Seattle, WA
Did you find this review helpful?
2 star rating Most Helpful
Critical Review
JUL
1
2007
  As anyone knows who has regularly read my reviews knows I am a habitual NPR (National Public Radio) listener.  Those of us who listen and are members of our local Public Radio stations have our favorite shows, but A Prairie Home Companion which airs every Saturday afternoon at 5:00 p.m.… read full review »
A Public Radio Member

TheBard
Aurora, IL
Did you find this review helpful?

A Prairie Home Companion Ratings and Reviews

items/page: 15 | 30 | 50 displaying 1 to 6 of 8 sort by: most helpful | date | rating


3
helpful
votes
comedy fan, a fan of clever plots, character-lover, learning to love the old radio shows

NOV
25
2007
I have been going down to my parents home on Saturdays to help out and drive back in the early evenings. I like to like to listen to the radio, but was getting tired of the music I was listening too so I thought I would do the old flipping of the stations.  — I have seen the movie "A Prairie Home Companion" and knew that it was a old radio show, but didn't know it was still on. So I thought I would take a listen in and see what is was about via the radio.  — I am hooked!  I laughed I cried and now a huge fan of this show. It airs on Saturday nights (Please check… read full review »
Did you find this review helpful?
5 star rating
AmyA
Appleton, WI



2
helpful
votes
a DVD collector, a fan of cheap-seat movies, a movie guru

AUG
1
2007
As anyone knows who has regularly read my reviews knows I am a habitual NPR (National Public Radio) listener.  Those of us who listen and are members of our local Public Radio stations have our favorite shows, but A Prairie Home Companion which airs every Saturday afternoon at 5:00 p.m. after All Things Considered Weekend Edition, is not one of mine.  I find the program just a touch too cutesy and boring for my tastes.  — And so I was a bit surprised when it was announced the a movie would be made from the rather bland radio broadcast (staring) the real live host… read full review »
Did you find this review helpful?
2 star rating
TheBard
Aurora, IL



Reviews continue below ad
D
a DVD collector, a movie guru, DVD collector, a fan of clever plots, character-lover, movie buff, horror fan

NOV
15
2007
The cast of this movie is great. With the legandary Meryl Streep and the hilarious Lily Tomlin you would think that this would be a great movie. However, it is quite the contrary. This movie is boring and the radio show is very boring and almost puts you to sleep. The underlying plot of the the troubles between and mother and her daugther is one of the best parts of this film, but it is not really brought into the forefront. The singing is good but the songs are not. This is not the best move and I don't really reccomend… read full review »
Did you find this review helpful?
3 star rating
egyptianmonkey2
Fairmont, WV



D
A Public Radio Member, Movie guru, Lover of quirky, unique films

NOV
13
2007
As an NPR listener and fan of Prairie Home Companion and Garrison Keiler, in general, I found this film to be largely disappointing. Altman has done wonders with ensemble casts (e.g. Nashville, M*A*S*H), but this is not one of his exemplary works. The film drags on, the storyline is inane and unnecessary and the ending in unsatisfactory. All in all, I'd save my money and go see a live show of Prairie Home Companion, any day. —… read full review »
Did you find this review helpful?
1 star rating
reviewer
fluxmaster
Los Angeles, CA



D
a lover of quirky unique films, character-lover, a fan of clever plots

DEC
11
2007
Waste of talented actors like Meryl Streep, Lily Tomlin, etc. The movie wasn't surreal enough to be quirky. The story was bizarre and not in a good way. The mysterious character remained just that; never did figure out who or what the girl in white was.I'm not a big Robert Altman fan, but unlike his other films that are at least watchable, this one wasn't. — Do not recommend. — … read full review »
Did you find this review helpful?
1 star rating
reviewer
settle4more2
Richmond, VA



D
a fan of clever plots, into movies that tell a great story

DEC
16
2007
I wasn't really sure what category this movie belonged in: Fake documentary, quasi-supernatural, coming of age/understanding adults...Little bit of everything. — It's been awhile since I saw this movie but I remember that the plot left you unsatisfied and, at times, confused. I like the cast, plus or minus a couple people, but really, kind of a strange movie.… read full review »
Did you find this review helpful?
2 star rating
reviewer
NDS
Warren, MI



Reviews of A Prairie Home Companion